Is Maple Syrup a Healthy Sugar?
Sugar

Is Maple Syrup a Healthy Sugar?

Perhaps you’re like Ross from “Friends,” often finding yourself indulging in a box of maple candies to the point of intoxication. (If not, don’t start now.)
(Brent Hofacker/Shutterstock)
September 29, 2023
Updated:
January 15, 2024
0:00
This is part 6 in The Ultimate Guide to Kicking Sugar

In this series, we will explore the good and bad sweeteners, uncover the unexpected outcomes of cutting out sugar, and discover the ultimate way to achieve this.

Maple syrup is undeniably sweet and tasty. Perhaps you’re like Ross from “Friends,” often finding yourself indulging in a box of maple candies to the point of intoxication. (If not, don’t start: This is a bad idea.) When consumed in moderation, maple syrup is indeed healthier than standard refined sugar.

Some might even consider maple syrup a superfood.

“If you’re stranded on a deserted island and could bring only one food, maple syrup is the food for you,” Navindra Seeram, professor and chair of the department of biomedical and pharmaceutical sciences at the University of Rhode Island College of Pharmacy, said during an interview with The Epoch Times.

How Is Maple Syrup Made?

Maple syrup is a natural sweetener extracted from the sap of maple trees, collected and concentrated without the addition of any chemicals. The method for collecting maple sap and making syrup was introduced to early North American settlers by Native Americans. It takes about 40 liters of tree sap to make 1 liter of maple syrup.

Sap collecting to make maple syrup typically starts in late winter or early spring, usually from February to March, and lasts only a few weeks. Maple trees accumulate starch during growth, which is converted into sugar during the spring thaw. This sugar then mixes with water absorbed by the tree’s roots to form maple sap. As the pressure changes due to rising temperatures and the ground thawing, maple producers bore holes into the tree, and taps are installed, allowing the sap to flow from the trunk.

Holes are bored into the trunks of maple trees to tap maple sap. (Marc Bruxelle/Shutterstock)
Holes are bored into the trunks of maple trees to tap maple sap. (Marc Bruxelle/Shutterstock)

Maple syrup can vary significantly from region to region and tree to tree. Fascinatingly, maple syrup’s characteristics continuously evolve throughout the entire harvesting season. At the beginning of the season, the syrup is relatively clear with a slight sweetness. As the season progresses, the syrup becomes darker and develops a range of distinct flavors, including vanilla, hazelnut, floral, and coffee, and can even be spicy.

Canada is responsible for about 75 percent of the world’s maple syrup production, and its syrup is classified into two primary grades: Canada Grade A and Canada Processing Grade. Then, Canada Grade A is further graded into four color classes:
  • Golden: delicate flavor
  • Amber: rich flavor
  • Dark: robust flavor
  • Very dark: strong flavor
Canada Processing Grade maple syrup doesn’t have color classes and is commonly used for large-scale commercial applications.

Composition of Maple Syrup: Effect on Blood Sugar Levels

Based on data from the U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA), sugars comprise about 60 percent of maple syrup, while water accounts for 32 percent.

Maple syrup contains three types of sugars: sucrose, glucose, and fructose. Sucrose is a disaccharide composed of one glucose molecule and one fructose molecule, accounting for 98.3 percent of all sugars in maple syrup, followed by glucose (1.1 percent) and fructose (0.6 percent).

While sucrose makes up most of the sugar in maple syrup, the glycemic index (GI) of maple syrup is lower than that of sucrose, with maple syrup having a GI value of 54 (pdf) and sucrose having an average GI value of 66. This means that consuming an equal amount of maple syrup compared to sucrose would result in a relatively smaller increase in blood sugar levels.

“Maple syrup is a much better option than refined sugar. It’s actually sweeter, which is beneficial because you can get away with using less of it,” Amy Gonzalez, a registered U.S. dietitian, told The Epoch Times. In other words, a smaller amount of maple syrup is required to achieve the same level of sweetness compared to refined sugar.

She explained that we can reduce the amount by a quarter when using maple syrup as a substitute for regular sugar in cooking. For example, if a recipe requires 1 cup of white sugar, 3/4 cup of maple syrup would suffice.

The Nutritional Value of Maple Syrup

In contrast to refined sugar, primarily composed of sucrose, maple syrup contains a diverse range of more than 250 substances. These compounds either occur naturally in the maple tree or are formed during processing.

“It also contains a cocktail of other substances,” Mr. Seeram said.

Maple syrup contains oligosaccharides, organic acids, amino acids, vitamins, and various minerals. It’s also rich in phenolic compounds, which exhibit a range of biological activities.

There are more than 67 grams of carbohydrates in 100 grams of maple syrup. It also contains 225 milligrams of potassium; 109 milligrams of calcium; magnesium, manganese, zinc, and iron; and trace amounts of thiamin, riboflavin, and niacin.

Maple Syrup’s Health Benefits

Mr. Seeram said maple syrup contains numerous substances that warrant further research and development. Its phenolic compounds exhibit a range of beneficial activities, including anti-mutagenic, anti-radical, antioxidant, anti-inflammatory, anti-diabetic, and even anti-cancer properties.

1. Anti-Diabetic

Blood sugar levels rise when food is broken down and absorbed by enzymes. Inhibiting these enzymes is considered an important strategy for treating Type 2 diabetes.
Maple syrup extract is rich in phenolic compounds, including ethyl acetate and butanol, which can inhibit the enzymes responsible for breaking down starch into sugars. These compounds can also hinder the enzymes that aid in the absorption of sugars in the small intestine, slowing the rapid digestion of carbohydrates and suppressing post-meal blood sugar.

Abscisic acid (ABA) found in maple syrup is believed to have potential anti-diabetic properties. This plant hormone shares structural similarities with a class of anti-diabetic drugs known as thiazolidinediones, and animal studies have demonstrated the protective effects of ABA against Type 2 diabetes.

A study conducted at Laval University in Canada revealed that compared to brown rice syrup, corn syrup, and pure dextrose, consuming maple syrup resulted in more minor fluctuations in blood sugar and better responses in insulin secretion and other related indicators.
Compared to brown rice syrup, corn syrup, and pure dextrose, consuming maple syrup results in more minor fluctuations in blood sugar levels. (The Epoch Times)
Compared to brown rice syrup, corn syrup, and pure dextrose, consuming maple syrup results in more minor fluctuations in blood sugar levels. (The Epoch Times)

2. Anti-Inflammatory and Antioxidant

Stress, physical injuries, viral infections, exposure to chemical substances, and other factors can trigger the release of toxic substances from cells, including free radicals. Oxidative stress caused by excessive free radicals has been linked to aging and various degenerative diseases, including cancer, heart disease, multiple sclerosis, Parkinson’s disease, autoimmune diseases, and dementia.
Research has confirmed that phenolic compounds in maple sap and syrup exhibit antioxidant activity and can scavenge free radicals. A study published in the Journal of Medicinal Food indicated that while pure maple syrup’s ability to clear free radicals is lower than that of blueberry juice, it’s comparable to orange and strawberry juices. Additionally, darker varieties have more pronounced antioxidant activity due to their higher phenolic content.

3. Anti-Cancer and Anti-Mutagenic

Maple syrup contains various phenolic compounds, including kaempferol, luteolin, quercetin, myricetin, and catechin, which exhibit potent anti-tumor and anti-mutagenic properties.
It can inhibit the growth of various cancer cells, including prostate, lung, breast, and colorectal. It’s worth noting that in experiments, maple syrup specifically targets rapidly growing cancer cells while leaving normal cells unaffected.
Maple syrup extract also protects cells and can counteract the mutagenic effects caused by toxic chemicals.

4. Unique Phenolic Compound: Quebecol

Quebecol is a unique chemical compound discovered in maple syrup in recent years, believed to possess anti-inflammatory properties. Interestingly, it isn’t naturally present in maple sap and is found only in small quantities in maple syrup. “The chemical is produced during the transformation of the sap in maple syrup, which requires lots of heating and boiling and evaporation,” Normand Voyer, a professor at Laval University’s department of chemistry, told The Epoch Times. He and his colleagues have developed a method for synthesizing quebecol, and scientists worldwide are now studying the substance.

“The source of inspiration was nature,” Mr. Voyer said, noting that nature also serves as inspiration for many other drugs on the market. “Nature serves us in providing beautiful chemical structures and natural substances that are unique.”

In lab studies, quebecol has shown significant potential in treating inflammatory diseases. For instance, it has been proven to positively affect conditions such as periodontitis and psoriasis.

How to Choose Maple Syrup

Before using maple syrup as a substitute for refined sugar in your diet, it’s crucial to read the product labels and instructions carefully.
Some maple syrup products may actually be high-fructose corn syrup with added maple flavor, with a GI value of up to 68, much higher than that of pure maple syrup. Long-term high artificial sugar intake can lead to metabolic disorders such as insulin resistance, abdominal fat accumulation, and high blood lipids.

Look at the ingredient labels and select those that are 100 percent real maple syrup.

Additionally, when selecting maple syrup, choose darker-colored varieties, as they contain more phenolic compounds.

Despite its benefits, it’s important not to eat too much maple syrup.

“First and foremost, it is indeed a sweetener. You should not use a large amount of any sweeter,” Mr. Seeram said.

“Do I believe that it is a functional sweetener or smarter sweetener [than] unrefined sugar? The answer is yes,” but, he added, “you should drizzle, not guzzle.”

According to the 2020–2025 Dietary Guidelines for Americans (pdf), developed by the USDA, limiting the intake of free sugars to less than 10 percent of total daily calories is recommended. For someone with a daily calorie intake of 2,000 calories, the upper limit of free sugar intake would be 200 calories. Sixty milliliters (approximately 1/4 cup or 4 tablespoons) of maple syrup provides 270 calories.
The British government takes it a step further in its recommendations, suggesting that the energy from free sugars should be limited to below 5 percent. This means that for adults, the total daily intake of free sugars shouldn’t exceed 30 grams, equivalent to less than 40 milliliters of maple syrup (1 tablespoon has 15 milliliters).
When it comes to healthy natural sugars, coconut sugar often comes to mind for many people. Remarkably, coconut sugar boasts numerous health benefits that aren't widely known.