What for many years used to be considered a taboo topic—menopause—recently has become a source of much debate both inside and outside the medical community.
Is Menopause Overmedicalized?
The opening editorial to The Lancet’s series states that the overmedicalized view of menopause is misguided.The term “overmedicalized” can be vague, Dr. Heidi Nelson, a professor in the Department of Health Systems Science at the Kaiser Permanente School of Medicine in Pasadena, California, told The Epoch Times in an email. “As used in the Lancet articles, [overmedicalized] describes how the experience of menopause has been reduced to a medical problem requiring treatment without considering social, cultural, and political influences, or personal context,” she said. But people should not conflate the word “overmedicalized” with “overmedicated.”
Dr. Nelson said the short-term treatment of vasomotor symptoms with hormone replacement therapy (HRT) to reduce hot flashes, night sweats, and sleep disturbances and to improve vaginal dryness with hormones is appropriate for women and would not be considered overmedicalization.
Dr. Louise Newson, a general practitioner in the UK who specializes in menopause, told The Epoch Times via email that “menopause is more than a collection of symptoms; it is a cardiometabolic and inflammatory condition which leads to an increased risk of numerous diseases.”
Dr. Newson says many of the symptoms of menopause have been misdiagnosed, leading to the prescription of drugs, including antidepressants, antipsychotics, painkillers, sleeping pills, anticholinergics to treat bladder symptoms, and heart-related medications to lower cholesterol, reduce blood pressure, and control palpations.
Social Media Influencers
Doctors, celebrities, and social media influencers are all speaking up about this phase of a woman’s life, offering a wide range of advice. Even a quick search of the term “menopause” on Instagram returns a slew of accounts claiming to specialize in menopause treatment and therapy.Many women’s health practitioners have expressed frustration that celebrities and media headlines are making too much of a fuss about menopause, particularly on social media.
The Risks vs. Benefits of Hormone Replacement Therapy
The effect of hormones and women’s monthly cycles became a topic of controversy when a now well-known study called the “Women’s Health Initiative” (WHI) reported in 2002 that estrogen plus progestin treatments resulted in a 26 percent increase in breast cancer in postmenopausal women. This led to an early halt to the study that began in 1993 and was supposed to run until 2005 to determine whether or not hormone replacement therapy (HRT) could reduce the risk of heart disease, the No. 1 cause of death for women.Still, others claim that the benefits of symptom management with HRT must be balanced with the risks of its use for chronic disease prevention.
Dr. Newson is an advocate for body-identical HRT. “Unlike the old-fashioned types of HRT, body-identical HRT is very safe,” she said. “And for most women, the benefits of body-identical hormone replacement will significantly outweigh any risks. For most women, there are no risks of replacing their missing hormones.”
HRT may not effectively alleviate many of the symptoms women often attribute to menopause. According to Dr. Nelson, hormones primarily reduce hot flashes, night sweats, and vaginal dryness, symptoms specific to menopause. “The other symptoms attributed to menopause are not caused by menopause itself but can coexist,” she said. Women’s sleep disturbances are likely related to the hot flashes, resulting in brain fogginess or mood fluctuations during the day, and other more specific treatments should be used for these symptoms. Dr. Nelson suggests using cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT) or antidepressant medications, which can be more effective in treating anxiety and depression.
‘Menowashing’
Dr. Nelson expressed concern about the increased public focus on menopause leading to a proliferation of products in the marketplace claiming to alleviate symptoms targeting women who “are vulnerable and seeking help anywhere they can find it.” She cautions women to be wary of aggressive marketing.Dr. Newson said women can find everything from supplements to chocolate marketed for menopause, each claiming to help ease their suffering. “While it can appear sympathetic, consumers can easily misunderstand the supposed benefits for them.” She refers to these marketing tools as “menowashing.”
“The missing piece in the room here is that there is an enormous and very, very lucrative industry around certain products and services to women around menopause,” Dr. Newson said. Educating women about how to take charge of their health is vital to reducing the impact of marketing.
The one thing most experts agree on is that treatment for menopause symptoms cannot be a one-size-fits-all approach. Both sides are adamant about female empowerment. This means putting women at the center of the issue and trusting they are intelligent and capable of making informed decisions about their own treatment in partnership with their health clinicians.